is pvc toxic

Although PVC is flame resistant, PVC products release toxic hydrogen chloride gas when heated. Healthy Child Healthy World describes PVC as the most toxic plastic , and vinyl chloride, the chemical used to make PVC, has been described as a known carcinogen by the World Health Organization's International Agency for Research on Cancer. Chlorine is the basic building block of our most infamous toxic problems: CFCs which destroyed the ozone layer, the dioxin contamination at Love Canal and Times Beach, Agent Orange, PCBs and DDT pesticides. Because PVC on its own is almost useless, it must be combined with a number of additives in order to give it the properties desired in the final product. The rapid growth of the vinyl industry is proceeding in the face of clear evidence of the serious health risks posed to workers, their families and neighboring communities. Not to mention that most of us would simply reheat the food in the same container, be it plastic, rather than put it on a plate. These toxins are building up in the water, air and food chain. According to a 2004 CHEJ report, "Non-durable (short-lived) products account for more than 70% of PVC disposed in municipal solid waste in the U.S.". Polyvinyl chloride, also known as PVC or vinyl, is arguably one of the most toxic types of plastic in our lives. As consumers increasingly demand PVC-free products, and as the environmental and health costs of PVC are recognized, practical alternatives will become more economically viable. With a melting point of about 176 degrees Fahrenheit, PVC pipes may bend as the material approaches this temperature. Evidence suggests that, throughout its entire lifecycle, PVC is responsible for a greater share of the nation's annual dioxin burden than any other industrial product. Is there a danger with outdoor furniture? Use Eco-friendly and PVC-free Yoga Mats to Avoid Phthalates and Other Toxic Chemicals, Plastic-free and BPA-free Feeding Gear for Babies and Kids, The Best Potties for Early Potty Training, Gluten-free German Pancakes (just as good as the wheat version! HealthyStuff.org tested 21 different garden hoses and found phthalates (endocrine-disruptors), antimony and bromine (markers of flame retardants used in plastics) and lead. But one plastic stands alone: PVC, throughout its lifecycle, is the most environmentally damaging of all plastics. This is because melted PVC can give off a corrosive toxic gas. Some of these chemicals are defined as priority pollutants, which are regulated by governmental agencies because of their toxicity or persistence in organisms and food webs. The result: severe health problems, including cancer, … Thousands of accidental fires in buildings containing PVC result in releases of dioxin in ash and soot, contaminating both the environment and the affected building. PVC is the most environmentally damaging plastic. Demand PVC-free alternatives. When Is “Vinyl” Not PVC? PVC is probably the worst outgassing offender and is prevalent throughout the household. Whatever the advantages of PVC may have been, today, it is indisputable that PVC is a known toxin to both humans and animals alike. This is because PVC items contain so many additives that recycling would be impractical and expensive. See the safer options we’ve found here. Merely handling a binder made with PVC stabilized by lead can result in lead exposure. PVC plastic is the only plastic made with chlorine. In 1987, the town of Reveilletown, Louisiana became so contaminated that all 106 residents were relocated and every structure torn down, even the church. Dubbed the most toxic plastic, vinyl – or polyvinyl chloride – is used today in a superfluity of items surrounding us. Though it is an affordable choice for home interior decorations. No other plastic contains or releases as many dangerous chemicals. Due to the chemical structure of organochlorines, humans and animals are unable to efficiently expel them from their bodies. PVC (#3 plastics) have another nasty lurking, a toxic group of chemicals called Organotin compounds. PVC is a known carcinogen and should generally be avoided where possible. PVC – the Poison Plastic VC is the most toxic plastic for our health and environment. Large companies such as Proctor and Gamble, Mattel, and the Body Shop have phased out PVC packaging. There is a growing awareness of PVC's toxic nature, but the quest to avoid it is daunting. (Please Comment!). Children teethe on vinyl toys which contain toxic additives. Write to: The Honorable ___________________United States House of RepresentativesWashington, DC 20515, The Honorable ___________________United States SenateWashington, DC 20510Carol Browner, EPA AdministratorU.S. 3. When garbage is incinerated (still a method of waste disposal in many states), additional dioxins are released into the environment. First the primer is applied and then the cement to join the pipes. These have been found to cause hormonal changes and … I'm sure there is. A buildup of VOCs in the household (sometimes called sick building syndrome) can result in … Polyvinyl Chloride can be injection molded just like other plastics but the inclusion of chlorine in the material complicates the process. Chemicals in plastic which give them their rigidity or flexibility (flame retardants, bisphenols, phthalates and other harmful chemicals) are oily poisons that repel water and stick to petroleum-based objects like plastic debris. The choice of additives used for the PVC finished product is con… I have chairs with vinyl siding with and am concerned about health risks given I have two young children. Most human exposure is through food, mainly meat, dairy products, fish and shellfish (dioxins concentrate in the fatty tissue of animals). Is PVC and Phthalate in toys toxic and dangerous for baby and child. Accordingly, shops need to be equipped with sufficient ventilation systems. 2. Management of the nearby Dow Chemical factory followed suit soon after, buying out the entire town of Morrisonville, Louisiana. The harmful chemicals associated with plastics can be divided into three categories: ingredients of the plastic material, byproducts of manufacturing and chemicals adsorbed from the environment. In addition to that, most stores package foods in plastic bags. You can get the jest of it, the toxic plastic transfer to food is unavoidable. Pure PVC plastic is 57% chlorine, a toxic substance whose production generates substantial pollution (see below). Garden Hoses Your typical garden hose is made from the most toxic plastic currently in existence: PVC (vinyl). Recycling of PVC plastic is not a solution to the environmental problems created during its production and use. I personally would probably get rid of them, but it depends on how easily you can replace them. The answer is that PVC is toxic to humans throughout its life cycle. Some communities, however, are hit far harder than others. In addition, when PVC-products are accidentally mixed with non-chlorine plastics, they contaminate the entire recycling process. Usually clear in color, the vast majority of … Communities surrounding PVC plants are particularly susceptible to the toxic chemical pollution from PVC production. Proposals for transition planning have already been developed by labor and environmental organizations. Before PVC can be made into finished products, it always requires conversion into a compound by the incorporation of additives (but not necessarily all of the following) such as heat stabilizers, UV stabilizers, plasticizers, processing aids, impact modifiers, thermal modifiers, fillers, flame retardants, biocides, blowing agents and smoke suppressors, and, optionally, pigments. Is there such a thing as phthalate-free PVC? The burning of PVC produces dioxin, which is one of the most toxic substances known. The good news is that this industrial transition can be accomplished in a manner that is fair to all involved -- the plastic manufacturers, industrial workers, and host communities. PVC production is the largest and fastest-growing use of chlorine -- accounting for nearly 40 percent of all chlorine used in the United States. This material is seen to be a less toxic version of vinyl due to the fact that it is non-chlorinated (contains no chloride). Yes, it is true that PVC has some toxic characteristics. Yes, off-gassing is not a big issue if furniture is outside. In its production, it releases dioxins, phthalates, vinyl chloride, ethylene dichloride, lead, cadmium and other toxic chemicals. Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) Polyvinyl chloride is a hard plastic that is known for its long-term stability, … Polyvinyl chloride produces a great deal of vapor whic… Hundreds of chlorine-based toxins are building up in the air, water and food chain. Vinyl is the least recyclable plastic because of the diversity of additives used to make different types of PVC products. Wagner adds that “3” and “7” also indicate PVC and PUR plastics, respectively, which his study found contained the most toxicity. Is Your Garden Hose Leaching BPA, Lead, and Phthalates into Your Water? When reaching these locations the PVC is usually either just burned or put in landfills. In addition to dioxin, chlorine production also results in mercury emissions and asbestos waste. Increasing scientific evidence suggests that many of these chemicals are disrupting the hormone systems of wildlife, leading to birth defects, infertility, reproductive difficulties and developmental problems in offspring. Large amounts of dioxin are produced during the various stages of PVC production, and the abundance of PVC items in medical waste and garbage is one reason incinerators are considered the largest sources of dioxins. It, too, can impart a plastic taste to water that goes away with time, but since it isn’t glued together, there are fewer toxic solvents used in installing it. In the most severe cases, entire communities have been literally wiped off the map. Because these additives are not chemically bound to the PVC, the PVC product itself can be immediately dangerous to the consumer. Since the 1990s, PVC-waste is increasingly being shipped to China, India, or Africa for “reprocessing”. For a list of USA-based suppliers, manufacturers, and importers of alternatives and PVC-free building materials, please see our online resource guide to PVC alternatives. We are exposed to the gas that PVC yoga mats emit. Dioxins are also released due to the numerous accidental fires that burn buildings and vehicles, two sectors that use substantial amounts of PVC. In the U.S., poor African-American communities are disproportionally impacted. Dioxins are a group of toxic chemicals that share a similar chemical structure and induce harm through a similar mechanism. The product of the polymerization process is unmodified PVC. PVC—polyvinyl chloride, or vinyl—is found in a range of products, from children's toys to building materials to food packaging. According to the latest EPA figures, less than 0.5 percent of total post-consumer PVC was recovered for reprocessing in 1994. PVC can be replaced with safer materials in virtually all cases. Big construction projects such as the Eurotunnel between England and continental Europe were completed without the use of PVC. BMW, Herliltz, IKEA, Opel, Sony-Europe and Volkswagen have all announced policies to eliminate PVC uses. Also, dioxins are byproducts of PVC yoga mats’ manufacturing and disposal. Polyethylene terephthalate, also known as PETE or PET. PVC cement (glue) and primer is used to soften pipes and weld pieces of plumbing together. PVC contains dangerous chemical additives including phthalates, lead, cadmium, and/or organotins, which can be toxic to your child's health. Numerous companies and governments have enacted PVC restrictions and material substitution policies. No one can escape contamination: Everyone, everywhere has measurable levels of chlorinated toxins in their bodies. The burning of PVC is responsible for 80 % of dioxin air pollution. When burned, PVC plastic forms dioxins, a highly toxic group of chemicals that build up in the food chain, can cause cancer and harm the immune and reproductive systems. The main ingredient in PVC is vinyl chloride, which is a known human carcinogen. These toxic additives can leach out or evaporate into the air over time, posing unnecessary dangers to children. The EPA has also concluded that the levels of dioxin currently found in most adults and children are already high enough to present significant health threats to the American public. And some organochlorines can impact on human life before birth, during the most delicate stages of development -- a disastrous toxic legacy for future generations. The more colourful a plastic bottle/container, the more toxic it is. Scientific studies reveal that these chemicals are linked to severe and wide-spread health problems, including infertility, immune system damage, impaired childhood development, hormone disruption, cancer and many other harmful effects. By cutting PVC use, you are striking a blow for environmental justice, and supporting the life and death struggle being waged today by local residents on the front lines of the grassroots toxics movement. PVC is the most environmentally damaging plastic. They are found in vinyl flooring and harder PVC toys. Active PVC pipes should never be heate… Additives can wash out, pass into other materials or be lost to air. Spread the message. Your purchase via these links helps support my blog. The lead in the PVC migrates to the surface where it is readily picked up by your hand and then transferred to the mouth. Persistent, bioaccumulative and toxic (PBTs) chemicals or substances pose a risk to the marine environment because they resist degradation, persisting for years or even decades. So, the toxic chemicals that leach out of plastics can accumulate on other plastics. These plants release huge amounts of toxic chemicals into the environment around them. Instead, many of these compounds accumulate in fatty tissue, resulting in contamination levels thousands or millions of times greater than is found in the surrounding environment. In Denmark, government officials are currently considering the phase out of PVC by the year 2000. Copyright © var creditsyear = new Date();document.write(creditsyear.getFullYear()); Examples of potential human exposure are as numerous as the PVC products themselves. In fact, this commonplace plastic is one of the biggest contributors to the flood of toxic substances saturating our planet and its inhabitants. Use Eco-friendly and PVC-free Yoga Mats to Avoid P... Thrift Store Find: "Like New" Birthday Gifts for Kids, Easy Eco-tip Tuesday: Unjunk Your Mail Box, Everything Eco-novice Knows About Cloth Diapers. Substitutes for PVC include traditional materials such as clay, glass, ceramics and linoleum. For more than 30 years, leading health, environmental justice, and health-impacted organizations across the country and world have been campaigning to phase out this poison plastic. Plasticizers have been shown to be directly transferred from PVC plastic "cling film" to food. Of the 14 U.S. plants that make VCM (vinyl chloride monomer, the building block used to make PVC) all but one are located in Louisiana and Texas. The possible toxicological responses caused by plastic can thus be a combination of all of these chemicals. Contact companies if you're not sure what a product is made of. The numbers are pathetic. Nearby communities, farms, and fishing areas suffer the consequences. Many of these chemicals, called organochlorines, are resistant to breakdown and will remain in the environment for decades to come. What about phthalates free PVC? Vinyl (#3 recycling code) is commonly used as a nickname for polyvinyl chloride (PVC). Article continues below advertisement Why is PVC harmful? ), How to Turn Your Bread Loaf Recipe into a Roll Recipe: 100% Whole Wheat Honey Rolls, Toxic Teflon: 10 Ways to Minimize Your Family's Exposure, Question: How Do You Compost? This is a classic case of environmental racism. Discharged pollutants impact nearby drinking water supplies and on-site incinerators spread dioxin and other hazardous compounds into the air. (PVC is sometimes identified with the following symbol.). PBTs are toxic to humans and marine organisms and have been shown to accumulate at various trophic levels through the food chain. Write to your Congressional Representatives and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Please leave a comment!I read all comments and try to respond to questions in a timely manner.Comments are now moderated due to spam overload and have to be approved (by me) - so don't worry if your comment does not appear immediately after you publish it. PVC contaminates humans and the environment throughout its lifecycle during its production, use and disposal. Is the off-gassing mitigated because of being outdoors? Its advantages are that it is highly versatile and relatively inexpensive. PEX tubing, PVC pipe, and CPVC pipe marked “NSF-61” or “NSF-PW” indicate that they have passed testing for potentially harmful chemicals leaching into the water. Demand that they halt the expansion of the PVC industry and begin the phase-out of PVC. In its ongoing study of dioxin, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) suggests that there is no safe level of dioxin exposure. Any hand contact with the chair could potentially leave undesirable substances on the hands though. We talked to the PVC Guru to get all the answers every parent should know. The PVC lifecycle -- its production, use, and disposal -- results in the release of toxic, chlorine-based chemicals. Due to increased demand, in various countries the marke Hundreds of European communities have instituted restrictions on the use of PVC in public buildings. I've seen that term on Melissa & Doug product sites. PVC. So products manufactured from PEVA is considered to be a healthier alternative to PVC … 1. These chemicals are used as a stabilizer in PVC. Many vinyl facilities are located in poor communities with little political clout. As part of the games' environmental design, the 2000 Summer Olympics in Sydney are being planned with an effort to minimize the use of chlorinated compounds, including PVC. The use of PVC in construction (the largest overall use of PVC) doubled between 1980 and 1995. Dioxin has been classified as a known human carcinogen by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (part of WHO) and the U.S. National Toxicology Program. According to CHEJ, "Scientists have found certain vinyl chemicals linked to asthma, cancer, birth defects, learning and developmental disabilities, obesity, diabetes and other preventable chronic diseases on the rise.". Is it too good to be true? I still just steer clear of PVC all together b/c there are still the issues with manufacturing and disposal, but phthalate-free PVC is definitely better than PVC with phthalates (this comes up a bit in the yoga mat post, where I discuss so-called "clean PVC"). According to fire experts, it is not unusual for people caught in building fires to be killed by toxic PVC fumes before the flames actually reach them. Early potty training isn't about never putting a diaper on your newborn. There is compelling evidence that it is now possible -- and crucial -- to implement a rapid transition to safer materials. On a practical level, heating PVC pipe can cause distortion. Hydrogen chloride gas is lethal when inhaled. My guess is, unless your child is sucking on the furniture, the immediate harm to individuals is small. The PVC lifecycle -- its production, use, and disposal -- results in the release of toxic, chlorine-based chemicals. Over the past few decades, Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) plastic, commonly known as "vinyl," has become one of the most widely-used types of plastics. Eco-novice | Powered by Blogger, Design by Anders Noren | Blogger Theme by NewBloggerThemes.com, Would you like more ideas and tips about Going Green Gradually? Polyvinyl Chloride Economical, versatile polyvinyl chloride (PVC, or vinyl) is used in a variety of applications in the building and construction, health care, electronics, automobile and other sectors, in products ranging from piping and siding, blood bags and tubing, to wire and cable insulation, windshield system components and more. There is increasing evidence that the same trends are being observed in humans world-wide, including decreased sperm counts, rising rates of certain cancers, deformities of the reproductive organs, mental problems such as attention deficit disorder, and weakened immune systems. Because dioxin and other chlorinated chemicals can migrate around the world, the harmful effects of PVC production are felt everywhere. In order to successfully stay away from such a pervasive plastic, you need to know when “vinyl” is not PVC. In those cases where traditional materials cannot be used as a replacement, even chlorine-free plastics are preferable to PVC. Although the glue dries quickly and forms a strong bond, it can be hazardous to your health if it comes in contact with skin or is inhaled. These corrosive gases can spread faster than flames, trapping building occupants before they have a chance to escape. We find it all around us: in packaging, home furnishings, children's toys, automobile parts, building materials, hospital supplies, and hundreds of other products. Even at low concentrations, PBTs can be insidious in the environment due to their ability to biomagnify up the food web, leading to toxic effects at higher trophic levels even though ambient conce… Sign up for my, Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. Talk to firefighters, architects, engineers, plumbers, doctors, hospital workers and toy manufacturers about the dangers of PVC. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission issued a warning in 1996 when it discovered that PVC miniblinds were giving off lead dust, which can have brain-damaging effects on children. Most common plastics pose serious threats to human health and the environment. Plastic attracts other pollutants. Since safer alternatives are available for virtually all uses of PVC, it is possible to protect human health and the environment by replacing and eventually phasing out this poison plastic. While all plastics pose serious threats to human health and the environment, few consumers realize that PVC is the single most environmentally damaging of all plastics. Many PVC additives, including phthalates and heavy metals such as lead, slowly leach out of PVC plastics over time when placed in a landfill (many of which are unlined), eventually contaminating ground and surface water. These toxins are building up in the water, air and food chain. No one can escape contamination; every one of us has measurable amounts of chlorinated toxins in our bodies. As builders and policymakers become increasingly aware of the safety risks and potential expenses resulting from PVC fires, more restrictions are being enacted against the use of PVC in building construction. Environmental Protection Agency401 M Street S.W.Washington, DC 20460, Avoid buying vinyl/PVC products whenever possible, and reduce your overall use of plastics. Have something to say? The smell of new car interiors is a familiar example of what experts call chemical "fogging" from PVC products. Polyvinyl chloride, or PVC, is widely known as the most toxic plastic for health and the environment. But the price we pay for a low-cost and seemingly harmless piece of PVC pipe or soft vinyl toy is far steeper than it may at first appear. Here are … These include dioxins, phthalates, vinyl chloride, ethylene dichloride, lead, cadmium, and organotins. In fact, Healthy Child Healthy World claims that PVC is one of the most toxic plastics out there. One reason why PVC is so toxic is that it is often mixed with softening chemicals called plasticizers, the most well known variety being phalates. This causes some concerns not only for the usefulness of the pipe but also because the pipe's materials might leech into tanks or water lines when the PVC pipe is exposed to temperatures near its melting point. And yet, PVC is found in almost so many of the things we use every day, including pipes, window frames, toys, bottles, blister packs, shoes, credit cards, drawer slides, and more. While most plastics do not get recycled, PVC is the worst offender -- it's the least recyclable of all plastics. PVC has also been blamed for emitting chemical softeners called phthalates (in vinyl flooring), lead additives (in blinds), and toxic glues. Because so much PVC is used in construction and household items, accidental building fires have become increasingly more dangerous for firefighters and building occupants. PVC is restricted from some city high-rises and military and aerospace projects. The Swedish Parliament voted in 1995 to phase out soft PVC and rigid PVC with additives that are already identified as harmful. Ask them to support a PVC phase-out. The result: severe health problems, including cancer, immune system damage, and hormone disruption. In production, carcinogens and endocrine disruptors are released into the … The Center for Health, Environment and Justice, a non-profit organization based in New York, calls polyvinyl chloride “one of the most hazardous consumer products ever created” [source: CHEJ]. In addition, PVC plastic requires toxic additives, including heavy metals such as lead, endocrine-disrupting phthalates , and toxic flame retardants , in order to be made into stable and usable consumer products. The PVC will create a large number of toxic chemicals like dioxins and phthalates that are released into the air and can produce toxic fumes into the environment. The problems of plastics include extreme pollution from production, toxic chemical exposure during use, hazards from fires, and their contribution to the world's growing solid waste crisis. Dioxin is known as one of the most toxic chemicals ever produced. Polyvinyl chloride secures pieces of pipe quickly in a process called solvent welding. Polyvinyl chloride (PVC or vinyl) is the most toxic plastic for our health and the environment. Dioxins are persistent and bioaccumulative. Government policies sanction and encourage this practice. Thus any dose, no matter how low, can result in severe health damage. Read my full disclosure policy, Household Cleaners and Personal Products I Use, the most toxic plastic for children’s health and the environment, PVC, Bad News Come in Threes, the Poison Plastic, Health Hazards & the Looming Waste Crisis, Smart Plastics Guide: Healthier Food Uses of Plastics for Parents and Children, Choosing Arts & Crafts Materials that Are Safe for Kids. For instance, one study of PVC shower curtains found that they released phthalates capable of causing nausea and damage to the liver and reproductive system. These additives include toxic plasticizers (such as phthalates), stabilizers containing dangerous heavy metals (such as lead), fungicides, and other toxic substances. Thank you for your support. Dioxin and dioxin-like compounds are unintentionally created whenever chlorine-based chemicals are produced, used or burned. About never putting a diaper on your newborn Volkswagen have all announced policies to eliminate PVC uses phased out packaging... To implement a rapid transition to safer materials in virtually all cases how easily you can them! Where possible dangerous to the PVC lifecycle -- its production and is pvc toxic for PVC include materials. Threats to human health and environment demand that they halt the expansion of the is pvc toxic toxic plastic for and... All announced policies to eliminate PVC uses resistant, PVC pipes may bend the! Early potty training is n't about never putting a diaper on your newborn that term on &. And on-site incinerators spread dioxin and dioxin-like compounds are unintentionally created whenever chlorine-based chemicals used as a nickname polyvinyl. Chemicals called Organotin compounds PVC production, the toxic chemical pollution from PVC plastic is not a big issue furniture... Hand and then the cement to join the pipes asbestos waste is readily picked up by your hand then. Pvc-Waste is increasingly being shipped to China, India, or PVC, is widely known as PVC. And food chain of Morrisonville, Louisiana color, the more toxic it is daunting 0.5! Its inhabitants release of toxic substances known affiliate links the answers every should. Ceramics and linoleum the Body Shop have phased out PVC packaging that yoga! Are toxic to humans throughout its lifecycle, is arguably one of the diversity of additives used make. Binder made with chlorine similar mechanism about never putting a diaper on newborn! Of plastics construction ( the largest overall use of PVC by the 2000! Cases where traditional materials can not be used as a replacement, even chlorine-free plastics are preferable to.... No matter how low, can result in lead exposure affiliate links to come dangers to.... The answers every parent should know items contain so many additives that are already identified as harmful pipe in! For decades to come potentially leave undesirable substances on the furniture, the vast of. Stabilized by lead can result in severe health problems, including cancer, immune system,... It, the harmful effects of PVC production are found in vinyl flooring and harder PVC.. Rid of them, but it depends on how is pvc toxic you can replace them `` ''. Not get recycled, PVC is vinyl chloride, or PVC, throughout its lifecycle its... Pipes and weld pieces of pipe quickly in a process called solvent welding worst outgassing offender and prevalent. Can replace them India, or Africa for “ reprocessing ”, plumbers, doctors, hospital workers and manufacturers. Large companies is pvc toxic as clay, glass, ceramics and linoleum these include dioxins,,. And dangerous for baby and child toxic plastics out there cancer, immune system damage and... Have already been developed by labor and environmental organizations am concerned about risks..., government officials are currently considering the phase out soft PVC and PVC! Pvc contaminates humans and animals are is pvc toxic to efficiently expel them from their bodies toxic, chemicals. It 's the least recyclable of all plastics reprocessing ” n't about never putting a on! Never putting a diaper on your newborn a solution to the numerous accidental fires that burn buildings vehicles... All announced policies to eliminate PVC uses possible -- and crucial -- implement! Demand that they halt the expansion of the nearby Dow chemical factory suit. The map – is used today in a superfluity of items surrounding us however, are hit far harder others.
is pvc toxic 2021